1999
Sean Carr, D, DePaul
Anders Cedergren, D, Cincinnati
Jason Cole, MF/D, Saint Louis
Courtenay Commander, MF/F, Louisville
Bryan Godfrey, MF, Marquette
Jack Jewsbury, F/MF, Saint Louis
Steve Lawrence, D, Marquette
Scott Lyons, MF/F, Cincinnati
Flavio Monteiro, F, UAB
Juan Munoz-Airey, MF, UNC Charlotte
Casey Stump, D, South Florida

1998
Crunch Brown, MF, UNC Charlotte
Dominic DaPra, F, Saint Louis
Sean Fraser, F, Memphis
Kyle Meador, MF, Cincinnati
Stephen Miller, S, UNC Charlotte
Jeremy Morales, GK, Louisville
Sean Reti, F, Marquette
Demetrio Sanchez, F, DePaul
Brantley Spillman, MF, UAB
Marty Tappel, MF, Saint Louis
George Zabaneh, F, Louisville

1997
Issiah Davis, F, Cincinnati
Shawn Faria, MF, Louisville
Nick Glaser, F, Memphis
Andy Hunter, MF, Marquette
Andrew Kean, D, Cincinnati
Stuart Langrish, F, Louisville
Donny Mark, D, Marquette
Rumbani Munthali, D, UAB
Chris Pierce, MF, UNC Charlotte
Myron Vaughn, F, Cincinnati
Goran Yabar, MF, Louisville

1996
Nick Bokern B, Saint Louis
Steven Brooks, F, Memphis
Eric Cole, Fr., MF/S, UNC Charlotte
Brian Covey, GK, Memphis
Chad Garofola, MF, Marquette
Erik Kuster, F, UAB
Pablo Pinzon, MF, UNC Charlotte
Stephen Pugliese, S, UNC Charlotte
Greg Ruebusch, F/MF, Cincinnati
Brian Waltrip, Fr., F/MF, South Florida
Dave Williams, B, Saint Louis

1995
Kevin Bateman, B, DePaul
Tony Carpenter, B, South Florida
Ken Costello, B, Saint Louis
Thomas Holmen, F, South Florida
David Hughes, MF, UNC Charlotte
Brian Lehky, F/MF, Marquette
Mike Moriarty, B, Saint Louis
Pat Moriarty, B, Saint Louis
Bryan Pearce, B, DePaul
Jacob Thomas, MF/F, Saint Louis
Jim Welch, GK, Marquette